Posts Tagged ‘secrets

05
Dec
10

Wikileaks undermines the case for transparency

Berlusconi corrupt? With his reputation?

Berlusconi corrupt? With his reputation?

So, Wikileaks has been in the news this week. The media would have us believe that Wikileaks are releasing thousands of massive secrets which will undermine security for the whole world. However, the drivel that has dribbled out so far is hardly Earth shattering. Russia is corrupt, Angela Merkel is risk averse, Berlusconi is on the take. Yawn yawn yawn. We know all this. The yanks think that Cameron is a lightweight. Ho hum.

What the media seem not to be taking into account is that these are just a lot of internal memos. U.S. Policy is not that Merkel is cautious and Berlusconi corrupt. These are just opinions expressed by diplomats and the opinions are very diplomatic. Prior to the details emerging the media would have had us believe that we were in for a deluge of state secrets. If the leaks show anything they show that the Americans are fairly straight and fairly astute in their judgement.

Normally I am in favour of complete transparency. Publish everything. Certainly the United Kingdom keeps too much information secret and the recent MPs expenses scandal shows that secrecy feeds corruption.

However, the information currently being leaked by Wikileaks is nothing specific. It is just a lot of emails. If the Emails released shed light on some government fraud or illegal activity then there would be some point in releasing it but just embarrassing diplomats because they expressed opinions that were critical provides no benefit to anyone and damages the cause of transparency and freedom of information.

Having said that, it seems odd that just as Wikileaks really hits the news the Swedish government issue an arrest warrant for Wikileaks founder Julian Assange for alleged “sex crimes”. Probably the real story is that the Swedish government, whether unwittingly or not, are colluding in a stitch up




Enter email address to receive notifications of new posts.

Join 180 other followers

Images

Low Tide

Low Tide

Low Tide

Low Tide

Low Tide

Low Tide

Low Tide

Eclipse? Pah!

Transition

Morning

More Photos

Jonesxxx on Twitter

  • #bbcaq Mark Serwotka has fixed view on everything like Thatcher. Ideologues R great rabble rousers but give me thoughtful pragmatist any day - 5 days ago
  • RT @monx61: No no no Mary. The point of politics is to have a vision and work towards that #bbcaq - 5 days ago
  • RT @Melonhead999: #bbcaq typical Labour saying we need to change to get elected, no, you need principles, argue them, people don't know wha… - 5 days ago
May 2015
M T W T F S S
« Apr    
 123
45678910
11121314151617
18192021222324
25262728293031

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 180 other followers